To treat or not to treat prostate cancer

Autopsy studies show that 50% of men over age 59 have prostate malignancy, and three out of four over age 85. One in seven North Americans will also be diagnosed with prostate cancer in their lifetime. Yet only one in every 28 men will die of prostate cancer! Obviously, not all men need to be treated.

A report in Nutrition Action says that most prostate cancers are harmless and before the PSA test became available, men never knew the disease was present. And Dr. Lawrence Klotz, chief of Sunnybrook Cancer Centre in Toronto, is concerned that unnecessary surgery or radiation treatment leaves some men with impotence, diarrhea and urinary incontinence.

Because of these complications, in 2012 the U.S. Preventive Service Task Force recommended that, because the harm exceeds benefit, men should not take the PSA test. The inventor of the test came to the same conclusion!

The problem is that some prostate malignancies are ‘pussy cat’ cellular changes, similar to gray hair, while others are like hungry tigers that kill. Now, more urologists, particularly in Canada, are saying there’s no hurry to rush treatment. Rather, it’s prudent to keep watch on low risk cancers using the PSA test, biopsies and the Gleason Score to separate low threat cancers from lethal ones.

The Gleason Score is determined by microscopic examination of a biopsy of the prostate gland. A pathologist analyzes the cellular pattern and gives a Gleason Score of 1 to 10. Dr Klotz informs patients with a Gleason 3 score that they have a pseudo cancer, part of the aging process. For those with a Gleason 6, Klotz says this is not a metastatic condition. And he believes that in older patients a Gleason 7 can be treated with surveillance. Even without treatment these patients live 15 or more years.

Klotz adds that since 1995 he has followed 1,000 Canadian men with localized prostate cancers using a PSA test every three to six months and a biopsy every six to 12 months. He has seen only 14 deaths due to prostate cancer and overall there was a 10 times greater chance of dying of causes other than prostate cancer.

Today a few cancer centers use an MRI to follow low-risk prostate cancers. But, whatever approach is used, there are no guarantees. For instance, a prostate biopsy may detect a low-risk malignancy. But there is always the chance it may have missed a not too friendly cancer. So the risk of under treatment does exist.

One also has to consider human psychology. Doctors have preached for years the importance of early diagnosis and treatment. So it’s hard for patients not to say, “Doctor you’ve diagnosed an early prostate cancer that may be not life-threatening, but you’re not going to do anything about it?”

Certainly, if you are in your late 60s or 70s, watchful waiting appears to be a prudent approach. As one famous U.S. urologist remarked to me, “Getting older is invariably fatal, cancer of the prostate only sometimes.”

But some patients find it impossible to live day after day knowing that prostate cancer is present even though it’s friendly. Klotz also reminds us that surgeons and radiologists make their living by operating and using radiation techniques to treat this disease, so there may be a tendency in that direction.

When a death occurs that should not happen it is a terrible tragedy. A tennis friend of mine once called saying, “I’ve had a PSA test that’s elevated, so my family doctor referred me to a urologist. Five biopsies of the prostate were normal. But he decided to do a sixth and it showed a bit of microscopic cancer. What should I do?”

He was 74 years of age so I told him to do nothing. Without treatment he would live at least another 15 years. But he could not accept living with a non-lethal cancer and agreed to a radical prostatectomy operation. He died of a pulmonary embolism as he was leaving the hospital, a totally needless death.

Unfortunately, patients and their doctors still need the Wisdom of Solomon to reach the right decision.

See the web site For comments

Just Posted

Women of Excellence Awards introduces ‘Women of Excellence in Construction’

Gala will take place June 19th at the Sheraton Red Deer

Check online to make sure you’re registered to vote in upcoming provincial election

Advance polls open Tuesday, April 9th to Saturday, April 13th

UPDATE: Christy Starling has been found

Red Deer RCMP thank the public for their assistance

Red Deer Legion Pipe Band celebrates National Tartan Day

The band is raising money for their trip to Scotland in 2020

Sharon and Bram head to Red Deer on final tour

The duo is celebrating their 40th anniversary farewell tour

VIDEO: Restaurant robots are already in Canada

Robo Sushi in Toronto has waist-high robots that guide patrons to empty seats

New Leger polls suggests federal Liberals lagging Conservatives

Overall, 31 per cent of respondents polled said they would vote for Justin Trudeau’s Liberals

Teen girl accused in plot to attack Kamloops school with weapons out on bail

Judge warned the girl she would be back in jail if she threatened to shoot anyone

Oil prices, Alberta election call cloud Stampede chuckwagon auction expectations

The top money bid last year came from Versatile Energy Services, Ltd.

Lacombe hosts 6th Invasive Species Council Conference at LMC

Council looks to protect native ecological environments in Alberta

Pot industry welcomes decreased edibles tax, but unhappy medical tax remains

Taxes can increase the cost of medical cannabis by as much as 25 per ceny

‘It has to send a message:’ Broncos families await sentencing for truck driver

Jaskirat Singh Sidhu pleaded guilty to 29 counts of dangerous driving and apologized in court

MPs continue voting marathon as Tories protest shutdown of Wilson-Raybould motion

Multiple MPs have resigned from Trudeau’s Liberal cabinet

Carbon tax, oil and gas investment dominate Day 2 of Alberta campaign

NDP pledges more oil and gas processing, UCP slams provincial and federal governments on carbon tax

Most Read