Reflecting on the new overtime changes in hockey

Four months ago, the NHL’s Board of Governors approved a couple of changes to the league’s rules.

The first change was the expansion of the league’s video replay rules to include a coach’s challenge. The other was a change in the overtime format.

Since the 2005 lockout, the overtime format has been a five-minute 4-on-4 overtime period followed by a continuous shootout. This season, both the NHL and the Western Hockey League have changed the five-minute 4-on-4 to a five-minute 3-0n-3 period.

After witnessing a 3-0n-3 overtime period for the first time at last Saturday’s Red Deer Rebels game against the Calgary Hitmen, I have to say that it is easily one of the best ideas the hockey world has seen in the last 10 years.

The fact that only six players (plus two goalies) are on the ice at once gives those players a lot more room in which to maneuver. They have more time to make a play and more space in which to do it, leading to a much quicker style of play.

The fact that teams have to choose between having two forwards and one defenseman or vice-versa, leads to more odd-man rushes, which, during a sudden-death overtime, can be the among the most exciting plays in the game.

I seriously don’t know if I’ve ever heard a WHL arena louder than the ENMAX Centrium was on Saturday night. It was an incredibly exciting five minutes that featured odd-man rushes going both ways and some beautiful saves on both sides.

So with all of this quick back-and-forth play, it begs the question – why do we still have shootouts at all?

Saturday’s game was awesome because of the overtime period. Unfortunately, though, the game wasn’t decided during that overtime period.

Although it looked like it would have been decided within the next two or three minutes, the action, which had been so pulse-poundingly exciting up until that point, ground to a halt as the teams retreated to their benches.

Then the teams started sending out player after player to take their penalty shots and I swear that the noise level died right down.

Now don’t get me wrong the shootout is a very exciting part of the modern game, I just think that it has been overshadowed by this new 3-on-3 showdown, which keeps the pace up while doing basically the same job.

So, that being said, I would like to see one of two things happen – either get rid of the shootout altogether and play 3-on-3 continuously until somebody scores or move to a 10-minute 3-on-3 frame before going to the shootout. This way, more games would be decided by a dramatic overtime goal as opposed to being decided in the shootout.

In my opinion, games are always more exciting when they are decided in overtime anyways. When they end thanks to a puck crossing the goal line rather than on a save, as so many shootouts are.

After all, how memorable would the 2010 men’s hockey gold medal game had been if it had been decided during a shootout instead of the way it did?

zcormier@reddeerexpress.com

Just Posted

5 tips for talking to your kids about cannabis

Health officials recommend sharing a harm reduction-related message.

Red Deer RCMP arrest man after vandalism spree

19-year-old man faces charges after windows were smashed at three different businesses

The 2018/19 Influenza Immunization Program begins Oct. 15th

Influenza immunizations will be available free of charge

Darrell Paulovich remembered after accident claims his life

A tragic accident claimed the life of a rodeo advocate over the weekend

Central Music Festival presents Matt Minglewood Oct. 18th

He performs Oct. 18th at the Elks Lodge

Secret supper clubs test appetite for cannabis-infused food ahead of legalization

Chefs are eagerly awaiting pot edibles to become legal in Canada

Koreas agree to break ground on inter-Korean railroad

The rival Koreas are holding high-level talks Monday to discuss further engagement amid a global diplomatic push to resolve the nuclear standoff with North Korea.

Flash floods kill at least 7 people in southwest France

Flash floods have left several people dead in southwest France, with roads swept away and streams become raging torrents as the equivalent of several months of rain fell overnight, authorities said Monday.

Trump to visit Florida, Georgia; search ongoing for missing

The death toll from Michael’s destructive march from Florida to Virginia stood at 17.

Canadians widely unaware of accomplishments of famous women, poll suggests

A new poll suggests Canadians have a lot to learn about the accomplishments of some of the country’s most famous women.

Temporary access allowed for residents of landslide-threatened B.C. community

The district says areas of access to the community of about 54 homes could be expanded, depending on advice from a geotechnical engineer.

Joint inspection planned for missing journalist at Saudi Consulate

Turkish officials have said they fear a Saudi hit team killed and dismembered Washington Potst reporter Jamal Khashoggi

Sears files for bankruptcy amid plunging sales, massive debt

The company started as a mail order catalogue in the 1880s

BREAKING: Prince Harry and Meghan expecting their 1st child in spring

The announcement of the pregnancy confirms weeks of speculation from royal watchers

Most Read