Defence takes aim at alleged victim’s testimony

The defence in Dustin Paxton’s torture trial focused final arguments Friday on what it called the alleged victim’s “vague and inconsistent” testimony.

CALGARY — The defence in Dustin Paxton’s torture trial focused final arguments Friday on what it called the alleged victim’s “vague and inconsistent” testimony.

Jim Lutz was in the third day of his attempts to question the credibility of each and every Crown witness in a trial that began over two months ago.

Paxton is charged with aggravated assault, sexual assault and forcible confinement and has pleaded not guilty. It’s alleged he beat and tortured his former roommate and business partner over a two-year period.

The 28-year-old alleged man, whose name is under a court-order publication ban, testified that he was starved, humiliated and beaten — sometimes severely — on an almost daily basis and forced to perform sexual favours for Paxton. Court heard the man was battered, bruised and emaciated when he was dropped off at a Regina hospital in April 2010.

“He talks in general terms. He was assaulted every day. He was injured all the time,” said Lutz.

But the alleged victim was unable to provide any detail and his testimony was peppered with “I don’t know,” “I don’t remember” and “I have no recollection,” the lawyer said.

“It is hard for the court to assess the reliability of his testimony. That randomness is the undoing,” he suggested.

“The reliability factor makes it suspect.”

Lutz said there isn’t any way to tie the individual’s physical injuries to his client

“There is no evidence that supports that. That in itself ought to raise reasonable doubt.”

As for the charge of sexual assault, Lutz said his client never asked his roommate to do anything, never touched him and completely denies that anything happened.

Lutz also said Robert Cannon, a key witness who testified he saw Paxton beat the alleged victim with a one-metre-long bamboo stick, has been proven to be nothing more than “a liar and a thief” who would break down and cry when the questioning got tough.

Cannon’s memory was shaky and he was unable to keep his story straight, Lutz said, who also suggested lead investigator Det. Doug Crippen “contaminated witnesses” by telling them that others were corroborating their stories.

Just Posted

Alberta RCMP investigating email threats sent to multiple businesses

The email threats are demanding Bitcoin payment

Celebrating diversity with Inclusive Schools Week

Westpark Middle School teacher says inclusive schools benefit everyone

RCMP Major Crimes Unit South lay charges in homicide

Rocky Mountain House RCMP responded to a call of a person in distress on the Sunchild First Nation

Red Deer Hospice Society celebrates expansion fundraising milestone

The $1,000,000 mark has been reached in the $5.2 million campaign

UPDATED: Calgary Police receive multiple bomb threats

Similar threats received across Canada and the United States

Omar Khadr wants changes to bail conditions

‘My life is held in suspension’, says the former Guantanamo Bay detainee

Coach accused of sexual assault says apology letter was misinterpreted

Dave Brubaker has pleaded not guilty to one count of sexual assault and one count of invitation to sexual touching

Give the gift of nature this holiday season

Please don’t be mad, but I bought you a moose

Aboriginal poet faces backlash for calling out NHL-themed totem poles

Rebecca Thomas says she received backlash for asking a drugstore chain to remove NHL merchandise

Some Kotex tampons recalled in Canada and U.S.

In some cases, tampon users sought medical attention “to remove tampon pieces left in the body.”

Sex-assault squad investigated eight incidents at Toronto all-boys’ school

The interim president of a Roman Catholic all-boys school rocked by student-on-student abuse allegations said the football program was cancelled for next year.

Coal power in Canada must disappear by the end of 2029, new regulations say

Canada has significantly cut its dependence on coal largely due to the closure of all coal plants in Ontario.

‘Naive approach’ to China at fault in Meng mess: Scheer

Conservative Leader Andrew Scheer called on the Trudeau government to “unequivocally denounce any type of repercussions to Canadians on foreign soil.”

Omar Khadr ‘a model of compliance,’ wants changes to bail conditions: lawyer

Former Guantanamo Bay detainee Omar Khadr is back in court today to seek changes to bail conditions.

Most Read