Canada is still on shaky ground

With the United States credit rating being recently downgraded and some European countries tittering on the verge of debt crisis, Canadians can rightly be proud of our AAA credit rating.

However, the recent market volatility combined with declining commodity prices should not make us too complacent.

There are serious external risks facing the Canadian economy which bolsters the need for a strong and credible plan to deal with deficits and debt problems at home.

If our government does not heed the warning signs, it risks not learning from past mistakes.

In June, the federal government tabled a plan to balance the budget in five years. To get there, the Conservatives forecasted revenues to grow at a robust average rate of 5.6% over the next five years while planning to hold program spending increases to an average rate of 2%.

The problem with this plan is that, while the federal government directly controls the amount it decides to spend – though Canadians should exercise healthy skepticism as the Conservatives’ track record on spending suggests it will be unable to hold the line at 2% – the government is exposed to revenue shocks that are beyond its control.

A balanced budget plan that relies on strong revenue growth is one with significant downside risk and little to no upside potential.

Lower than forecasted revenue growth will mean larger deficits for a much longer time period and significantly more government debt.

The same approach did not work in the 1980s and early 1990s as successive federal governments failed to balance the budget by trying to slow the growth in spending while hoping for higher revenues.

Like the incumbent Conservatives, the Progressive Conservative government in the late 1980s and early 1990s was at least notionally predisposed to lower levels of government spending and balanced budgets. But failure to eliminate the deficit came from the Progressive Conservative’s inability to constrain spending growth coupled with lower than expected revenues.

That ultimately resulted in ongoing deficits, mounting debt, and a downgrade in Canada’s credit rating in 1994.

And now, just two months after the 2011 budget was tabled, the current government’s fiscal plan is facing similar risks with signs of a slowing U.S. economy and the possibility of a double-dip recession increasing.

Given that Canada’s economy is heavily tied to the U.S., any material slowdown in the U.S. will likely have a negative impact on the Canadian economy, federal revenues, and the Conservatives’ deficit-reduction plan.

To reduce the frailty of the current fiscal plan and to set Canada apart from the rest of the world, the federal government must quickly balance its budget.

Finance Minister Jim Flaherty can use the government’s fall economic and fiscal update to do just that – balance the books in two years, not five.

To get there, Flaherty should ensure that program spending is returned to pre-stimulus levels. This can be achieved by greatly expanding the government’s Strategic and Operating Review, currently a one-year review of program spending – excluding transfers to individuals and governments – which proposes to find a mere 2% in savings from the $352.5 billion in departmental spending planned from 2012-13 to 2014-15.

The expanded Strategic and Operating Review ought to prioritize spending so that important areas are spared deep cuts while lower priority areas carry a greater burden of the spending reductions.

A good starting point is to significantly reduce, or better yet eliminate, corporate subsidies which have grown substantially under the Conservative regime.

A two-year balanced budget plan would reduce the risks associated with a revenue shock like a slowing U.S. economy.

With the U.S. economy is looking ever more fragile, sovereign debt concerns growing in Europe, and commodity prices softening, Canadians should feel increasingly uneasy about the government’s fiscal plan.

The newly minted Conservative government should use its majority to implement the type of balanced budget plan the Prime Minister and his colleagues once championed as members of the opposition.

Niels Veldhuis and Charles Lammam

The Fraser Institute

Just Posted

Blackfalds RCMP investigate break and enter at Fas Gas

RCMP search for suspect who cut through an outside wall to gain access

Operating Budget focuses significantly on community safety

Proposed 2% tax increase for operating budget, debate runs in January

UPDATE: Red Deer RCMP investigate non-suspicious death downtown

48 St. behind transit terminal was closed off earlier Wednesday

Team Canada dancer returns to Red Deer laden with medals

Red Deer dancer wins three silver medals and a bronze at World Championship

Local author releases brand new international thriller

Retired teacher Larry Stewart hosting a book launch this Saturday

Troubled Monk releases new spirit

Troubled Spirit vodka was introduced in early December

Google searches suggest 2017 a tough year

What were Canadians were curious about: Google searches suggest 2017 a tough year

Democrat wins stunning red-state Alabama Senate upset

Democrat Doug Jones wins stunning red-state Alabama Senate upset against Roy Moore

New fighter-jet competition to have national ‘economic interest’ requirement

Trudeau government wants to replace Canada’s aging CF-18s with 88 new fighters by as early as 2025

The top-binged shows on Netflix in 2017

Which show did you cheat on your spouse with by watching ahead?

2017 word of the year: Feminism

Merriam-Webster’s word of the year for 2017: ‘Feminism’

200 Russians to compete in Olympics as neutrals

The Russian Olympic Committee expects 200 to compete in South Korea

Researchers claim the ‘man flu’ does exist

Review of scientific studies suggests ‘man flu’ may be more intense: researcher

Trudeau appoints Supreme Court chief justice

Prime Minister Trudeau appoints Richard Wagner as Supreme Court chief justice

Most Read