‘Language’ matters in global warming debate


University of Florida linguist M. J. Hardman tells us that “Language is inseparable from humanity and follows us in all our works. Language is the instrument with which we form thought and feeling, mood, aspiration, will and act(ion), the instrument by whose means we influence and are influenced.”

It is not surprising then that language has always been a crucially important weapon of war. Delivered with convincing rhetorical flare, language has driven ordinary citizens to acts of self-sacrifice while pushing others to acts of barbarism.

And now, language tricks are being used to justify the unjustifiable in the increasingly intensive war of words over global warming.

“Climate change is real,” “We must stop climate change,” “All scientists agree.”

These are phrases used by environmental alarmists, politicians and industrialists to scare the public into supporting multibillion-dollar schemes that enrich the few at the cost of the many.

Happily, such assertions are beginning to lose their impact as the public comes to realize they are nonsensical.

However, one language mistake has become so entrenched that even those who oppose politically-correct thinking on climate change still use it unthinkingly.

We are told we must ‘reduce carbon’ or ‘carbon emissions.’ To do this, we need to engage in a tax on carbon, carbon trading, carbon capture and storage and even build up carbon credits to offset our carbon liabilities.

Last week in the House of Commons everyone from the prime minister to the ministers of natural resources, foreign affairs, and international trade, not to mention ordinary MPs from all parties, referred to the dreaded carbon tax that the NDP supports, or does not support, depending on who you believe. The phrase was used 35 times in the Commons debate on Sept. 20 mostly by government members.

Parliamentarians need to go back to their Grade 9 science textbooks before opening their mouths again on the topic. Carbon is a solid, naturally occurring, non-toxic element found in all living things. Carbon forms thousands of compounds, much more than any other element. Everything from medicines to trees, to oil, to our own bodies and those of all other creatures are made of carbon compounds.

But pure carbon occurs in nature mainly in only two forms: graphite and diamonds. So, are Canada’s politicians talking about taxing graphite pencils? Or diamond jewelry?

Perhaps they are speaking about soot emissions reduction since so-called ‘amorphous carbon’ (that is, carbon without structure) is the main ingredient in soot and that is certainly a pollutant important to control.

What is really being addressed by Canada’s politicians is one specific compound of carbon, namely carbon dioxide (CO2).

But CO2 is only one of thousands of compounds containing carbon. It really should be carbon dioxide tax, CO2 emissions, CO2 capture and storage (something that has yet to be demonstrated on a large scale and poses significant risks), CO2 emissions trading, etc.

It is not merely an academic point. Ignoring the oxygen atoms and calling CO2 ‘carbon’ makes about as much sense as ignoring the oxygen in water (H2O) and calling it ‘hydrogen.’

Imagine getting your next water bill on an invoice labeled ‘hydrogen tax.’ That might be an effective PR tool for anti-hydro power campaigners but most of the public would regard such a communications trick as ridiculous.

The ‘CO2-is-carbon’ mistake is no less farcical. Throwing a pencil into the air could be considered more of a ‘carbon emission’ than is the CO2 from coal stations.

This error is not harmless. It is part of the way language has been distorted to bolster concerns about human-caused climate change. Calling carbon dioxide ‘carbon’ encourages people to think of the gas as ‘pollution’ or something dirty, like graphite or soot. That is undoubtedly why Al Gore calls it carbon pollution.

Calling CO2 by its proper name would help people remember that, regardless of whether its rise is causing climate problems (a point of strong debate in the climate science community), it is an invisible gas essential to plant photosynthesis and to all life.

Politically correct but deceptive phrases such as carbon tax are dangerous because they influence millions of people and, ultimately, government policy.

Tom Harris is executive director of the International Climate Science Coalition.

This column is distributed through www.troymedia.com.

Just Posted

WATCH: Lacombe and Red Deer Chambers prepare members for cannabis legalization

Luncheon speaker educates businesses on marijuana policies

Crime statistics released for final quarter of 2017

December of 2017 showed no hike in break and enters and a notable drop in theft of vehicles compared to December of 2016

UPDATE: Highway 2 lanes were closed due to milk truck fire near Millet

A southbound truck hauling milk and cartons collided with a bridge

James Barker Band is ‘Game On’

Country group heads to Red Deer this month

UPDATED: Red Deer will officially be the home of the Canadian Finals Rodeo

CFR has potential to bring in an economic impact of $20-30 million

WATCH: Red Deer Entertainment Awards honours Red Deer’s burgeoning talent

The awards looks to become more inclusive of the entire entertainment scene in year three

B.C. out of the running for Amazon’s next headquarters

Toronto is the only Canadian city left in the running despite the province backing Metro Vancouver’s bid for new Amazon headquarters

Post interest rate hike debt tips

What to do about your debt and mortgages after the interest rate hike

Foreign workers sleeping in Alberta Burger King basement

Alberta Health Services said its inspectors found foreign workers sleeping in the basement of the Lethbridge restaurant

Court application halts release of bread price-fixing documents

Bread price-fixing documents won’t be unsealed Thursday, Loblaw says

Pharrell and N.E.R.D to headline NBA All-Star halftime show

11-time Grammy winner Pharrell and his hip hop-rock band N.E.R.D. will headline the halftime show at the 2018 NBA All-Star game in Los Angeles

Heritage Minister wants zero tolerance for harassment in entertainment industry

Heritage Minister Melanie Joly had two meetings to discuss harassment in the film, TV and theatre worlds

Newly freed Diab wants reforms to Canada’s ‘lousy’ extradition law

French authorities dropped terrorism charges against Hassan Diab who was suspected of taking part in an attack in Paris in 1980

Russia probes come up against claims of executive privilege

The argument was laid bare this week during Steve Bannon’s interview with the House Intelligence Committee.

Most Read