Alberta’s current budget reminiscent of 1988′s

In his 1988 budget speech, then Alberta finance minister Dick Johnston proclaimed the “government’s fiscal strategy of providing major stimulus worked.”

He said a “solid recovery” had begun and forecast a return to balanced books three years out. If that sounds familiar, it’s because in Budget 2011, Alberta’s newest finance minister, Lloyd Snelgrove, has channelled the 1980s-era minister: “We had a plan that got us through the recession and we will stick to it as government revenue now begins to recover,” said Snelgrove. He also forecasts a balanced budget three years out.

Alberta’s politicians have a habit of budgeting based on the assumption that boom-time revenues are permanent. They also have the tendency to not recognize overspending has created structural deficits.

For example, in 1981-82, real program spending was $9,183 per capita; that jumped to $11,383 by 1985-86. That set Alberta up for massive deficits once resource revenues declined.

Similarly, after ratcheting back real per-capita program spending later in the 1990s (it hit a low of $6,434 in 1996-97), such spending rose in most of the following years to reach $9,260 in 2006-07.

But a few years of exceptional natural resource revenues led Alberta’s government into temptation, and per-person program spending went even higher, to $10,134 by 2008-09.

Akin to the 1980s, such dramatic increases in program spending (never mind capital expenditures, which are also up sharply) set the province up for red ink once resource revenues moderated.

Thus, in addition to billions in red ink in the past two fiscal years, Alberta’s government forecasts another $8.9 billion in deficits between the year just ending and the targeted surplus in 2013-14.

But there are potential pitfalls for Snelgrove’s three-year estimate, just as there were in the late 1980s for another finance minister.

For one thing, the province assumes marginal increases in program spending over the next three years to $40.1 billion in 2013-14 from a forecast $38.4 billion in 2010-11. But containing spending is generally not something the Alberta government has been adept at recently.

Another significant problem is found in the province’s assumptions used to arrive at balanced books. For example, the province hopes a barrel of oil will be worth $95.75, that gas will be $5 a gigajoule and that the Canadian dollar will be worth 98 cents U.S. in 2014.

Perhaps. But beyond the foregoing, the finance ministry wouldn’t release its sensitivity assumptions to me for 2014. Thus, I’m forced to do a back-of-the-envelope calculation using sensitivity assumptions for the 2011-12 budget. Based on those, if in 2014, oil is $5 less than predicted, if gas is just $4.50, and if the Canadian dollar is worth 98 cents U.S., revenues will be $1.6 billion less than expected.

That would turn a predicted $1.2 billion surplus in 2013-14 into a $400-million deficit – even if the province can hit its spending target that year.

The upshot is this: As in the 1980s, Alberta is again eroding its net financial assets. In 1985, Alberta’s assets were worth $12.6 billion; but the subsequent nine years of deficits eroded the province’s position and led to a net debt of $8.3 billion by 1994. That was an almost $21-billion deterioration in nominal terms.

The same thing is happening now.

Alberta’s net financial assets hit a high of $39.4 billion in 2007-08, but are forecast to decline to $19.3 billion by 2013 (and that excludes pension liabilities that worsen the picture.) That’s a $20-billion deterioration in nominal terms.

That’s not as severe a decline as in the last deficit era, especially after inflation, but it’s the trend that counts, and we’re at the beginning.

Arresting that decline will depend on whether the finance minister’s wish for a balanced budget by 2013-14 materializes.

Missing from budget 2011 was the question of how to balance the books if revenues are less than expected.

Wages, benefits and salaries are the largest part of any government’s budget (once the health care and education sectors are included, and not just direct ministry employees). If Alberta is to balance the budget any time soon, such expenses must be part of any balanced budget program. That and other options should be on the table.

Mark Milke is the director of the Alberta office of the Fraser Institute. His column is distributed through Troy Media.

Just Posted

RCMP offer crime prevention tips for the holiday season

Red Deer RCMP give tips so holidays aren’t marred by theft or damage

Dan Davidson up for five ACMA Awards

Davidson will head to Red Deer with Brett Kissel in the New Year

Sagmoen neighbours recall alleged hammer attack

Woman was screaming outside Maple Ridge townhouse in 2013

RCMP lay 34 charges in stolen vehicle operation

Red Deer RCMP arrest 13 people in four-day covert stolen vehicle operation last week

Last Christmas for Ten Thousand Villages in Red Deer

The fair trade organization will be closing its doors in the New Year

Troubled Monk releases new spirit

Troubled Spirit vodka was introduced in early December

Firefighter dies, thousands more take on California blaze

This is second death linked to the Thomas fire, northwest of Los Angeles

FCC votes along party lines to end ‘net neutrality’

Move rolls back restrictions that keep big providers from blocking services they don’t like

Truck driver volunteers to take dog lost in B.C. back home to Alberta

Frankie, a pit bull service dog, was found wandering in the Lower Mainland

Disney buying part of 21st Century Fox in $52.4B deal

Disney is buying a large part of the Murdoch family’s 21st Century Fox for about $52.4 billion

Bountiful polygamist believed he couldn’t be prosecuted: lawyer

Winston Blackmore’s lawyer says Blackmore did not believe he could be prosecuted

Woman charged after altercation injured baby in Toronto

Charges have been laid after a four-month-old baby girl was critically injured in Toronto

Ottawa Senators forward Chris Neil announces retirement

Veteran Ottawa Senators forward Chris Neil spent 15 seasons with the NHL team

Trudeau’s office confirms staffer being probed over allegations

PMO confirms staffer being probed over allegations of reported “inappropriate behaviour.”

Most Read