Johnnie Bachusky

Lennie Briscoe smiles at Canada’s highest court

Imagine for a moment you have been arrested by police, taken to the cop shop and then brought to an interview room where Mounties announce they want to have a chat with you.

One begins with something like, “There was a homicide downtown and we think you might be responsible.”

Horrified, you then take a line from Law & Order and tell the Lennie Briscoe-like cops, “I want a lawyer.”

But sadly they don’t instantly leave like they do in television land. The police here in Canada have no ‘Miranda rights’ to follow and the Supreme Court of Canada (SCC), has just made sure of that for what could be a long time.

Earlier this month the SCC, ruling in three separate cases in which suspects demanded during an interrogation to speak to counsel, refused to import American “Miranada rights”. Police gives these to suspects in custody before they are interrogated to inform them about their constitutional rights. When the American Supreme Court made its “Miranada rights” ruling in 1966 it was held that a suspect in custody must be clearly informed of the right to consult with a lawyer and to have that lawyer present during questioning.

Forty-four years later the SCC, in a tight 5 – 4 majority ruling, is turning its back on that American high court ruling.

“Adopting procedural protections from other jurisdictions in a piecemeal fashion risks upsetting the balance that has been struck by Canadian courts and legislatures,” wrote Madam Justice Beverley McLachlin and Madam Justice Louise Charron on behalf of the SCC in the majority ruling. “We are not persuaded that the Miranda rule should be transplanted in Canadian soil.”

But SCC judges speaking on behalf of the minority assailed the majority opinions, accusing the ruling of “tightening the noose” around the Charter right to counsel.

“What now appears to be licensed is that a presumed innocent individual may be detained and isolated by the police for at least five or six hours without reasonable recourse to a lawyer – during which time the officers can brush aside assertions of the right to silence or demands to be returned to his or her cell in an endurance contest in which the police interrogators, taking turns with one another, hold all the important legal cards,” said Justice Ian Binnie in a dissenting opinion.

Meanwhile, most defence lawyers across the country are also unhappy with the decision, particularly since it can only be reversed by legislative change or if the SCC should reconsider its position, which would be a rare move by the high court.

“I think there is a potential for abuse,” said Red Deer criminal defence lawyer Kevin Sproule. “I fall on the side of liberty, freedom and granting our citizens as much as that as possible, and that would include protection from abuse by investigators who might otherwise be inclined to press things in an unfair manner. Yes, I am concerned.

“It certainly is going to put more of an onus on the individual to listen to their lawyer’s advise when they are told they have a right to remain silent,” added Sproule. “But whether people are going to have the practical ability to withstand potentially hours of harsh questioning and sleep deprivation that remains to be seen. “Hopefully that won’t happen but I am afraid we are going to have to trust our police forces not to abuse their authority.”

We can certainly hope our trust will bear fruit. But the fact in Canada now is that Lennie Briscoe’s job has been made a lot easier. And that should be scary for everyone.

jbachusky@reddeerexpress.com

Just Posted

Let the Games begin!

Team Alberta takes home gold and silver in speed skating on day one

‘Mitts don’t just warm hands. They warm hearts’: Mitts for Many Program launches

Donate new or lightly used mittens to bin in the Great Hall of the Gary W. Harris Centre

WATCH: Historic night in Red Deer as 2019 Canada Winter Games kicks off

Star-studded Opening Ceremony welcomes athletes from across Canada

Athletes’ medals unveiled at the official opening of 2019 Canada Winter Games

Medals depict Central Alberta landscape and pay tribute to First Nations

Red Deer RCMP arrest man after vehicle theft from dealership

Police were able to disable the SUV with assistance from the built-in vehicle assistance system

Fashion Fridays: Up your beauty game

Kim XO, helps to keep you looking good on Fashion Fridays on the Black Press Media Network

Ontario police field complaints over Amber Alert for missing girl, 11, found dead

Some said the Amber Alert issued late Thursday for Riya Rajkumar disrupted their sleep

LOCATED: Innisfail RCMP looking for missing woman

Amanda Kucher was last seen at the Innisfail 7-Eleven on Feb. 15

Red Deer College transforms into Athletes’ Village

Red Deer College’s campus will be home for the athletes during the 2019 Canada Winter Games

Alberta minor hockey team, slammed for Indigenous dance video, forfeits season

Parents say season was too dangerous to finish because the team has been threatened

Trump officially declares national emergency to build border wall

President plans to siphon billions from federal military construction and counterdrug efforts

Father to be charged with first-degree murder in Amber Alert case

11-year-old Riya Rajkumar was found dead in her father’s home in Brampton, Ontario

Red Deer man loses car after being caught twice driving with suspended licence

The Ponoka Integrated Traffic Unit ticketed the man in December and on Valentine’s Day

January home sales were weakest since 2015, average national price falls: CREA

CREA says the national average price for all types of residential properties sold in January was $455,000

Most Read