The truth behind changes to minimum down payments

The federal government recently announced changes to minimum down payments on properties priced below $1 million.

Many headlines are oversimplifying and inaccurate. The change is not as simple, nor as painful, as a jump to 10% down on homes over 500K — this is not the correct math at all.

It is a sliding-scale increase, meaning that the extra dollars required rise gradually (i.e., a $675,000 home now requires a down payment of $42,500 or ~ 6.3% down — NOT 10%).

As such, the impact on markets is expected to also be gradual and marginal, save for possibly Calgary where an already cooling market needs anything but further restrictions.

One might ask why further restrictions for prime borrowers are required at all in a nation with historically (and consistently) low arrears rates. Mortgage arrears rates have come down from their ‘high’ of 0.43% in 2009 to a current 0.29%.

The answer is, in a word, optics.

There is an undeniable statistical link between the amount of equity homeowners have in a property and those same homeowners’ likelihood of falling into arrears or foreclosure.

More equity = less risk. The optics of this change appear as good governing. This looks like an effort to moderate rapidly rising prices in the two largest markets (Toronto and Vancouver) and increase stability.

This regulatory change also has a net effect similar to a subtle increase in interest rates from the Bank of Canada.

More restrictive lending guidelines are far more targeted than the Bank of Canada moving interest rates, which affect the entire economy, not just real estate.

Moving interest rates is simply too big a macro-economic lever to lean on in an effort to slow, or lower, home prices in just two cities of the nation.

This brings us to U.S.A.’s decision to hike their own interest rates by 0.25%, a first in nine long years.

There is much fanfare around this being a signal that the U.S. economy is resilient and recovering. Perhaps so, but the increase itself is marginal and it will be the quantity and pace at which any further hikes are introduced that will tell the entire story.

Interestingly, this move acts for the Bank of Canada as a de facto rate cut here.

It will further soften the Canadian dollar against the U.S.

Arguably, this will lower the chances of the Bank of Canada reducing Prime at their next meeting. Economists are still predicting no movement in the Canadian prime lending rate for 2016.

In other words, no action on CDN interest rates is expected in either direction anytime soon.

Jean-Guy Turcotte is a mortgage broker with Dominion Lending Centres – Regional Mortgage Group in Red Deer.

Just Posted

Klaus testifies he falsely confessed to triple-homicide in Mr. Big sting

Klaus said confessions were made in order to further position within criminal organization

Red Deer River Naturalists host guest speaker

Bradley Peter will talk about new methods of lake monitoring

Superintendent Ken Foster sees progress in city policing

Red Deer RCMP Superintendent has been on the job for a year and has seen success

Accused Jason Klaus testifies in triple-homicide trial in Red Deer

Klaus charged with three counts of first-degree murder, one count of arson

WATCH: Red Deerians come together to ‘light the night’

Traditional Red Deer Lights the Night sees thousands

BC RCMP hunt for white SUV that rammed cruiser

Kamloops RCMP are looking for a white SUV headed north on the Yellowhead Highway

Canadian screen stars want ‘action’ from industry meeting on sexual misconduct

‘Of course there’s been sexual harassment here. Absolutely. No question.’

Opioid prescriptions up across Canada: report

The report shows the number of opioid prescriptions rose by almost seven per cent, while daily doses on average dropped

Russian meddling has implications for Canada

Kosovo president Hashim Thaci warns that Russian meddling has implications for Canada

Health Canada hints at government’s plans for legal pot

Health warnings, plain covers for pot packs under proposed regulations

Washington governor tells BC don’t be ‘daunted’ by Trump

“I want to assure this assembly that no matter who is in the White House, it won’t affect Washington state’s relationship with Canada or British Columbia.”

Feds plan to spend billions on housing strategy

However much of the $15.9 billion will not be spent until after the next election in 2019

David Cassidy, teen idol and ‘Partridge Family’ star, dies at 67

Cassidy announced earlier this year he had been diagnosed with dementia

Most Read